When I first began writing about the “doctor” title, I lead with my personal beliefs but as my research expanded I realized there were so many variables and so many experiences that have shaped other women’s views on being called “doctor.”
Call me “doctor,” please
A few years ago I was at a charity event for underprivileged kids in Detroit. One of the board members was a well-spoken nurse with a PhD. She introduced herself as “doctor” and I admired that. She earned it. The title automatically told of her accomplishments in one simple word.
My boyfriend at the time was also a member of the board. As we were networking, I asked him to introduce me as “doctor” because I was too embarrassed to do it myself. I’ve always appreciated it when my friends would introduce me as doctor in professional settings. It took the pressure off me. He told me that I was being arrogant, and continued to introduce me as “Rozy” the rest of the night. Was I being petty? Was I being overly sensitive? It was a disappointing night, and it shaped my feelings on being called doctor. I speak up for myself now. I earned it.
On a pedestal
On the other hand, an article titled I’m a physician. But please don’t call me doctor examined another perspective from a female surgeon. She states that using “doctor” is impersonal and creates a distance among her co-workers and more importantly, her patients. This makes her feel isolated. She also strongly viewed using the title as authoritarian like, and described doctor as someone “on a pedestal” and not using the term showed her “humility,” thus reinforcing the notion that “doctor” is an arrogant term and title.
Unnoticed by most, this also categorizes the term doctor as traditionally “masculine” because of it’s aggressive perception.
One of my great guy friends from undergrad recently got married. He also completed his medical degree and is in a cardiology fellowship. His lovely wife is a smart and beautiful pharmacist. As the DJ introduced them as Dr. and Mrs., I almost leapt out of my chair to announce to everyone that indeed his wife was also a doctor. I called him after the wedding to ask his viewpoint on what happened with the introduction. He said that he did notice, and that it was actually planned. WHAT? His wife made the decision to be called Mrs. that day because to her it reflected the significance and celebration of marriage. It was much more about her personal life that day. I understood her viewpoint, but I also pointed out that a male doctor would never be referred to as Mr. at a wedding. We both agreed that would probably never happen, but I was happy to hear that the two of them were aware of the gender bias with the doctor title and had a conversation about it before the wedding. It was her choice.
The choice to be called doctor or not
A colleague told me a story of when she was introduced by her first name at a hospital meeting while all the male physicians in the room were referred to as “doctor.” I was surprised, but it turns out her story is common. Dr. Shannon Lorimer, a prominent orthopedic surgeon, shared a shocking photo (seen above) of notes left for her physician’s group in which all male colleagues were referred to as doctor, while the rep used her first name.
Last month a paper called Speaker Introductions at Internal Medicine Grand Rounds: Forms of Address Reveal Gender Bias validated these occurrences and the feelings of being gypped of the doctor title. It is the women who get overlooked. The authors analyzed introductions at grand round lectures and found that women referred to their male and female colleagues as doctor 96% of the time, whereas men referred to their male colleagues as doctor 76% of the time, and female colleagues as doctor only 49% of the time. This is a striking difference.
“Failure to acknowledge a woman’s hard-earned professional title while men are awarded theirs, even when unintentional, has profound implications and reinforces the perception of women having lower status.”
Overall, I’m glad this has started an important conversation, and it’s been eye opening to see other perspectives of of female colleagues. Being called doctor or not doesn’t really bother me much anymore, but only if it’s my choice.
This was a really great read and I enjoyed the insights and different viewpoints. At the same time it was infuriating to know that in 2017 this is really still happening and it is blatant disrespect to female doctors.
I’ve noticed this phenomena too. While almost all of my colleagues prefer I call them by their first name, I watched helplessly as Attendings will address male residents with their title while using the first name of the female residents when rounding at patient’s bedside.
Even though I’m granted privilege of using first name in address, I consider that for our face-to-face communication. I *always* refer to all my physician colleagues as ‘doctor’ in front of patients. It defines our roles clearly – I am a very old male nurse and I am very protective of my role, and that of my physicians. We work as a team and our roles matter, our titles define those roles for our patients.
Every time I see this happen I take the attending aside and remind them of this fact, and that failing to enforce that for all my residents, regardless of gender, diminishes our professions.
Thank you so much for sharing your experience and for being a true ally to female physicians! You’re 100% right that working as a team is key, and you going above and beyond to make your female physician colleagues feel welcomed and respected as part of the team is truly touching. I appreciate you!